Get A Quick Quote

Get A Quick Quote

Comprehensive Health Insurance Solutions

Independent Senior Insurance provides real advice and solutions to complex health insurance questions and issues. We strive to provide the correct answer for our clients needs. Our specialty is Medicare and Individual health plans.


How can we help you today?

Three people in a home office reviewing documents and smiling during a professional consultation.
A logo for Independent Senior Insurance featuring a blue hexagon icon with an
A pair of black, rounded quotation marks centered on a white background.

Your agency made my insurance experience truly exceptional.


- John Doe

Who We Are

About Our Agency

Since 2010, Independent Senior Insurance has served Carmel and the surrounding Indiana communities by protecting the people we work with just like we protect our own family members.​


​If you're not thrilled with your current insurance contact us today. 



A simple black-outlined icon of a thumbs-up gesture.

100% customer satisfaction guaranteed

A black-and-white icon of a circular rosette award ribbon with two tails hanging down.

National Insurance Company of the Year

A black shield icon containing a simple white checkmark.

Best Rates & Coverage in Carmel

A grid of 28 black dots arranged in four rows of seven against a white background.
Two people wearing glasses smile while looking at a laptop together at a wooden table.

Knowledge Hub

Five people smiling and posing for a group photo in an indoor setting, with one person waving to the camera.

Medicare Supplement

Medicare Supplement helps pay costs not covered by Original Medicare, lowering your out-of-pocket expenses.


A graphic design element featuring a semi-circle of seven evenly spaced black radial lines on a white background.
A person in a business suit points to a digital tablet held by a group of people at a table, all looking at the screen.

Medicare Advantage

Medicare Advantage bundles hospital, medical, and prescription drug coverage into one convenient plan.

A smiling couple stands in front of a truck filled with moving boxes and furniture, preparing for a move.

Health Insurance

Health Insurance covers medical expenses from illness or injury, helping protect your health and finances.



A smiling couple sits closely together on a couch, wearing casual plaid shirts and holding hands.

Dental Insurance

Dental Insurance covers preventive and restorative dental care, helping maintain your oral health and smile.

Learn More About Insurance

A simple, thick black wavy line centered horizontally against a plain white background.
A black horizontal wavy line on a white background.

Our Experts

Meet Our Team

Get to know the dedicated professionals behind our success, committed to serving you with expertise and care.

A smiling professional in a tan blazer stands in a bright office, holding a tablet.

Jennifer Smith

Agency Owner

A person in a black blazer and white shirt stands with arms crossed, smiling against a blurred, bright office background.

Amanda Warren

Commercial Lines

A smiling person with a beard and glasses wearing a navy blue blazer and white shirt stands with arms crossed in an office.

Michael Smith

Personal Lines

Client Reviews

What Our Clients Are Saying

Hear from our satisfied clients who trust us with their coverage, and experience the difference our dedication makes.

GOOGLE REVIEWS

A pair of black, stylized quotation marks on a plain white background.

The team at this agency is phenomenal. They handle everything quickly and professionally. Don't look any further for your insurance needs—give them a call today!


Miguel P.

I have so many different things to worry about right now. It means so much to me that I can trust all of this to a team I can trust 100%. Thanks to all of you!


Robert B.

If you're considering doing business with these guys don't waste your time going anywhere else. They're the best in the business. Call them today - you won't regret it.


Maria P.


The team at this agency is phenomenal. They handle everything quickly and professionally. Don't look any further for your insurance needs—give them a call today!


Miguel P.

I have so many different things to worry about right now. It means so much to me that I can trust all of this to a team I can trust 100%. Thanks to all of you!


Robert B.

FACEBOOK REVIEWS

A pair of black quotation marks.

I’ve never had such a positive experience with an insurance company. They made everything so easy. Highly recommend you call them!


Laura G.

I had so many questions, and they answered them all with patience. Great service and care! Don’t hesitate to call them today.


Ashley R.

Switching to this agency was the best decision I made. They found me great coverage at a better price. Highly recommend calling them!


Kevin S.


I’ve never had such a positive experience with an insurance company. They made everything so easy. Highly recommend you call them!


Laura G.

I had so many questions, and they answered them all with patience. Great service and care! Don’t hesitate to call them today.


Ashley R.

We’re ready to help!

Get In Touch With Us

We're here to help with any questions or needs. Reach out to our team for personalized assistance and expert guidance on your insurance.

A stylized line icon of a hand holding a gear containing a checkmark.

Tailored Insurance Solutions

An outline of the United States with five location pin icons scattered across the map.

Nationwide Coverage

A black-outlined shield icon containing a centered checkmark.

Peace of Mind Guaranteed

Contact Us

Location

3309 East 146th Street, Carmel, Indiana 46033, United States

Let's connect!

We're proud to represent great insurance carriers like:

The Cigna Healthcare logo features the blue text
The blue UnitedHealthcare logo featuring a stylized 'U' icon next to the company name.
The purple Aetna brand logo on a white background.
The Blue Cross Blue Shield logo, featuring a blue cross and a blue shield on a white background with text to the right.
The Humana logo with green text on a white background.
The Transamerica logo featuring a stylized red pyramid icon to the left of the brand name in blue text.

We're proud to represent great insurance carriers like: